I got a little bored so I decided to take the top 1000 players with the most games played all time from mlb.com and figure out what there ratings would be here are the top 25 for IF, OF and C. I'll try to do Pitchers later.

**IF **

442 Gehrig, L 1B

426 Greenberg, H 1B

418 Rodriguez, A 3B

413 Pujols, A 1B

408 Foxx, J 1B

401 Brouthers, D 1B

396 Stovey, H 1B

394 Cabrera, M 1B

387 McGwire, M 1B

387 Howard, R 1B

385 Bagwell, J 1B

382 Teixeira, M 1B

380 Thomas, F 1B

377 Trosky, H 1B

377 Delgado, C 1B

377 Anson, C 1B

376 Richardson, H 2B

374 Garciaparra, N SS

373 Hornsby, R 2B

373 Ortiz, D DH

371 Vaughn, M 1B

369 Connor, R 1B

366 Jones, C 3B

365 Allen, D 1B

364 Palmeiro, R 1B

**OF**

439 Ruth, B OF

433 DiMaggio, J CF

429 Thompson, S OF

413 Gonzalez, J RF

405 Williams, T LF

404 Belle, A RF

400 Delahanty, E LF

399 Ramirez, M LF

395 Simmons, A LF

394 Duffy, H OF

392 Aaron, H RF

390 Sosa, S RF

388 Canseco, J RF

386 Guerrero, V RF

384 Bonds, B LF

382 Kiner, R LF

381 Kelly, K RF

381 Mays, W CF

381 Averill, E CF

380 Griffey, K CF

378 Rice, J OF

377 Hamilton, B OF

375 Klein, C OF

375 Wilson, H OF

375 Tiernan, M OF

**C**

376 Ewing, B C

371 Piazza, M C

346 Berra, Y C

336 Bench, J C

330 Cochrane, M C

329 Dickey, B C

328 Rodriguez, I C

325 Lopez, J C

316 Fisk, C C

311 Posada, J C

309 Parrish, L C

307 Torre, J C

305 Munson, T C

303 Miller, D C

303 Carter, G C

300 Simmons, T C

296 Hartnett, G C

295 Farrell, D C

292 Tettleton, M C

286 Pierzynski, A C

285 Steinbach, T C

283 Molina, B C

283 Varitek, J C

282 Cooper, W C

282 Santiago, B C

The overalls might be off by 1 or 2 depending on rounding but it gives you a general idea. This list contains both active and retired players.